Top Picks for the Sweetest Brown Sugar Brands

Brown sugar, with its rich flavor and moist texture, is a must-have staple in many kitchens, enhancing both sweet and savory dishes. When it comes to selecting the best brands, quality and taste are paramount factors to consider. A variety of brands cater to these needs, each offering unique characteristics that make their products stand out. Below, we explore some of the top brands renowned for producing premium brown sugar.

Illustration of brown sugar

Best brands of brown sugar in 2025

Domino

Domino Sugar is renowned as one of the best producers of brown sugar, with a legacy spanning over a century since its brand name was adopted in 1901. The company processes approximately 6.5 million pounds of raw cane sugar daily, operating round-the-clock over three shifts Monday-Friday and 24/7 from September to January. Domino Foods, Inc. has a combined production capacity of 2.2 million metric tons of sugar per year, making it the largest marketer of refined sugar in the U.S. Their brown sugar products, including the newly introduced Golden Sugar, maintain naturally occurring molasses, adding a unique flavor and texture to recipes. Domino's commitment to quality and consistency has made it a trusted name in kitchens across the nation. For more details, visit the Domino Sugar website.

C&H

C&H Sugar is renowned as one of the leading producers of high-quality brown sugar, with a history dating back to 1906, and originally organized as a cooperative in 1921. The company processes approximately 700,000 tons of cane sugar annually, producing a diverse range of sugar products, including dark brown sugar, light brown sugar, and turbinado sugar. C&H Sugar's Crockett Refinery employs over 450 people and produces 14% of the nation's cane sugar. The company's commitment to using exclusive cane sugar, believed by many to be superior to sugar from sugar beets, sets it apart in the market. With more than 70 types, grades, and package sizes available, C&H Sugar caters to a wide range of consumer and industrial needs. For more in-depth information, you can visit their company blog.

Sugar In The Raw

Sugar In The Raw is a premium turbinado cane sugar brand, renowned for its all-natural and authentically sourced products. It captures the authentic taste of the tropics, sourced from select locations like Colombia and Mauritius where the tropical sun, fertile soil, and cool mountain waters create ideal conditions. The sugar retains its natural molasses flavor, resulting in golden, crunchy crystals that are never bleached. This brand has been a leader for over 50 years, maintaining its #1 position due to its rich flavor and high-quality production. Sugar In The Raw is also Non-GMO Project Verified, kosher certified, and suitable for vegan diets. For more information about their products, visit their Sugar In The Raw FAQ page.

Imperial Sugar

Imperial Sugar is a renowned brand in the sugar industry, particularly noted for its high-quality brown sugar products. Established in 1843, the company has a long history of producing 100% pure cane sugar and non-GMO products, ensuring consistent quality and taste. Recently, Imperial Sugar made a strategic move by acquiring a minority stake in an organic cane sugar producer in July 2023, expanding its presence in the growing organic sugar market with a focus on clean-label and sustainably sourced sweeteners. Their product portfolio includes light brown sugar, which is popular among consumers and industrial clients alike. With operations in several states including Georgia, California, and Louisiana, Imperial Sugar maintains a strong presence in the U.S. sugar market. For more information about Imperial Sugar, visit their company page.

Wholesome Sweeteners

Wholesome Sweeteners is a prominent brand in the brown sugar market, known for its high-quality organic products. The company is part of the global brown sugar market, which is expected to grow significantly, with the organic segment anticipated to be the fastest-growing at a CAGR of 8.7% from 2022 to 2027. Wholesome Sweeteners benefits from the increasing consumer awareness of health benefits associated with brown sugar, which includes additional nutrients like iron, calcium, magnesium, and potassium compared to conventional white sugar. The brand operates within a market that was valued at USD 17.10 billion in 2021 and is projected to reach USD 36.76 billion by 2029, growing at a CAGR of 10.04%. As a key player, Wholesome Sweeteners contributes to the market's growth driven by the expanding food and beverage industry and rising health consciousness.

Michigan Sugar

Michigan Sugar Company, under the Pioneer Sugar brand, is renowned for its high-quality brown sugar production, with the capacity to produce over 1 million 2-pound bags of brown sugar per week following a recent expansion. The company's Bay City operation has seen a 50% increase in brown sugar packaging capacity. In the 2020-2021 campaign, Michigan Sugar sliced 4,277,351 tons of sugarbeets and produced more than 1.17 billion pounds of sugar, with additional sugar extracted from molasses. The new molasses desugarization facility in Bay City will enable the company to extract sugar from 100% of its molasses, up from 60%. This investment underscores Michigan Sugar's commitment to maximizing sugar production.

Tate & Lyle

Tate & Lyle is a prominent player in the global brown sugar market, known for its high-quality products and significant market presence. As part of the industry leaders, Tate & Lyle contributes to the market's growth, which is expected to reach $38 billion by 2032 with a CAGR of nearly 11% from 2024 to 2032. The company operates within a market where the Asia Pacific region holds a dominant share, with countries like China and India driving high consumption levels. Tate & Lyle's involvement in the brown sugar market is part of a broader industry trend where health consciousness and the demand for organic products are on the rise, with the organic segment growing at a CAGR of 8.7% from 2022 to 2027. This growth underscores the company's commitment to meeting consumer demands for healthier and more sustainable sugar options. For more information about their offerings, visit their official website.

Zulka

Zulka is a renowned producer of high-quality, unrefined brown sugar, made from freshly harvested sugar cane and minimally processed to retain natural molasses and nutrients. This NON-GMO, vegan-friendly, and plant-based sugar offers a distinct caramel-like flavor and aroma, making it ideal for baking, sauces, and beverages. Zulka sugar is free from bone char, additives, and preservatives, ensuring purity and natural goodness. It can be used cup-for-cup as a substitute for white sugar and is available in generous 4-pound packages. With its commitment to sustainable farming practices and fair trade, Zulka stands out as a preferred choice for health-conscious consumers. For more details, visit Zulka's official website.

Billington's

Billington's is renowned as one of the best producers of brown sugar, known for its unrefined cane sugars that lock in the natural molasses of sugar cane, enhancing the flavor and aroma of various culinary creations. Their sugars, such as Dark Brown Soft Sugar and Light Brown Soft Sugar, are crafted with precision to maintain the natural richness and depth of flavor. Billington's sugars are ideal for baking, adding a unique taste to products like brownies, cakes, and puddings. The brand's commitment to ethical sourcing and high-quality production has made it a favorite among bakers and chefs. With its rich, treacle-like flavor, Billington's sugars are a staple in many kitchens. For more information, visit their official website.

Florida Crystals

Florida Crystals stands out as a premier producer of brown sugar, notably for its Regenerative Organic Certified(r) sugarcane, which is the only such certification held by a sugarcane grower in the U.S. Their organic light brown sugar, made from homegrown sugarcane on family-owned farms, features a perfect blend of added molasses for a moist texture and subtle caramel taste. This product is Non-GMO Project Verified, Vegan Action certified, Kosher, and USDA Organic Certified, ensuring high standards of quality. Florida Crystals' commitment to regenerative farming practices maximizes resources and generates renewable energy, making their sugars both sustainable and affordable. Their light brown sugar is ideal for recipes like chewy chocolate chip cookies, BBQ sauce, and carrot cake blondies.