Top Crib Mattress Brands to Ensure Sweet Dreams for Your Little One

When it comes to selecting the perfect crib mattress for your little one, ensuring safety, comfort, and quality are paramount. Many brands today offer a variety of options that cater to parents' different needs, ranging from organic materials to innovative design features for enhanced breathability and support. Companies like Newton Baby, Naturepedic, and Sealy have consistently been recommended for their commitment to producing high-quality, non-toxic crib mattresses that prioritize both infants' health and restful sleep. Below, explore our list of the top crib mattress brands that promise peace of mind and superior performance for your baby's nursery.

Illustration of crib mattress

Best brands of crib mattress in 2025

Newton Baby

Newton Baby is renowned for producing some of the safest and healthiest crib mattresses on the market, particularly with their innovative Newton Crib Mattress introduced in 2017. This mattress features Wovenaire(r), a material composed of food-grade polymer and 90% air by volume, ensuring high airflow and reducing the risk of suffocation. In tests, the Newton Crib Mattress showed a suffocation risk half that of competitors and measured significantly below the fatal airway obstruction limit at 2.12 cm H2O. This commitment to safety and quality has made Newton Baby a trusted brand among parents. The unique composition of their mattresses provides parents with peace of mind while their babies sleep. To learn more about the science behind the safety, visit their website.

Sealy

Sealy is a leading brand in the mattress industry, particularly renowned for its high-quality crib mattresses. With a market share of 15% in the overall mattress market, Sealy stands out for its safety, quality, and comfort, as evident from its Sealy Posture Perfect 2-Stage Hybrid Crib Mattress, which has been voted the healthiest crib mattress by parents in the Cribsie Awards 2020. This mattress features a hybrid coil and soybean memory foam design, ensuring a firm infant side and a softer comfort side for toddlers, meeting all the latest ASTM tests and is GREENGUARD Gold Certified. Sealy's commitment to safety and quality has made it a trusted choice, with more babies sleeping on Sealy mattresses than any other brand in the USA. The company's legacy, dating back to 1881, further solidifies its reputation as a reliable producer of crib mattresses.

Simmons Kids

Simmons Kids is a renowned brand in the crib mattress market, known for its commitment to safety and comfort. The brand is part of the Simmons Bedding Company, a key player in the industry, which contributes to the global crib mattress market's growth at a CAGR of 4.60% during the forecast period. Simmons Kids mattresses are favored for their high-quality materials and innovative designs, catering to the increasing consumer spending on child safety products. The brand's presence is significant, particularly in the home application segment, which accounted for the largest market share in 2020. With a strong market presence, Simmons Kids continues to be a trusted choice for parents seeking reliable and safe crib mattresses.

Graco

Graco is a renowned brand in the baby products industry, particularly known for its high-quality and safety-oriented crib mattresses. Graco's crib mattresses, such as the Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress, are designed with breathable, firm foam cores recommended for safer infant sleep and are backed by a 6-year limited manufacturer's warranty. These mattresses have received several awards, including the Parent Tested Parent Approved (PTPA) Seal of Approval and the 2021 JPMA Innovation Award. Graco's products are GREENGUARD Gold Certified, ensuring low chemical emissions, and are popular for their affordability, with prices starting at $119. Despite the competitive market, Graco remains a trusted choice for parents due to its long-standing reputation and compliance with stringent safety standards.

Moonlight Slumber

Moonlight Slumber is a renowned brand in the crib mattress market, known for its high-quality and safety-certified products. Their mattresses, such as the Little Dreamer and Luxury Dreamer, are praised for their breathable, waterproof, and hypoallergenic designs, and have received several awards, including the Mom's Choice Award 2024 and Baby Maternity 2023 PRODUCT OF THE YEAR AWARD. Despite past issues with misleading claims, the company has maintained a strong presence, with products that are UL GREENGUARD^® GOLD certified, ensuring low indoor air pollutants and off-gassing. Moonlight Slumber's mattresses are designed for both infant and toddler use, offering longevity and comfort. The brand is part of a growing crib mattress market expected to expand at a CAGR of 4.60% during the forecast period. For more information on their offerings, you can visit their Moonlight Slumber's product page.

Naturepedic

Naturepedic is a pioneering brand in the crib mattress market, known for its commitment to safety, sustainability, and quality. Founded in 2003 by Barry Cik, the company was driven by the need for safer, chemical-free mattresses for infants. Naturepedic uses food-grade polyethylene for waterproofing and avoids toxic materials like vinyl, phthalates, and polyurethane foam, making their mattresses superior in terms of health and safety. The brand has seen significant growth, expanding from crib mattresses to larger sizes, and is part of a market that is anticipated to grow with a CAGR of 5.7% through 2029. Naturepedic's focus on eco-friendly and organic materials aligns with the increasing consumer preference for sustainable baby products. For more insights into Naturepedic’s initiatives, visit their Leadership Business Member page.

Dr. Oz Sleep

Dr. Oz Sleep, while not specifically focused on crib mattresses, is renowned for its innovative sleep solutions, including mattresses and adjustable bed bases, which were launched in fall 2020 through a partnership with Maven. These products, available at Macy's, QVC, and on the official website, emphasize science-based design for better sleep. The mattresses, such as the Good Life Hybrid Premier, feature advanced technologies like SilverScience for cooling and antibacterial properties, and high-density polyfoam for durability. However, there is no specific mention of crib mattresses in the Dr. Oz Sleep product line. The brand's commitment to quality and sleep science makes it a trusted name in the sleep industry.

Colgate Mattress

Colgate Mattress is a leading brand in the crib mattress market, renowned for its commitment to safety and quality. The company invests heavily in research and development to create products that meet stringent safety standards, offering enhanced comfort and durability. As a key player, Colgate Mattress is part of a market expected to grow from $4.5 billion in 2023 to $6.8 billion by 2032, with a CAGR of 4.5% during the forecast period. The brand's focus on consumer education and awareness campaigns further strengthens its market position, building trust and credibility with parents. Colgate Mattress is particularly prominent in regions like North America, where high consumer awareness and substantial purchasing power drive market growth. For more details, visit their official website: Colgate Mattress.

Safety 1st

The Safety 1st brand is renowned for producing high-quality crib mattresses, particularly the Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress, which is known for its affordability and compliance with strict safety standards set by the Consumer Product Safety Commission. This mattress is made from a thermo-bonded fiber core and features a vinyl outer cover that is wipeable, making it easy to maintain. Despite its lower price point of $68-75, it provides the necessary firmness and comfort for infant sleep. However, it may not be as durable as more expensive options, requiring replacement after about 4 years of use. The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Crib Mattress is a popular choice for parents due to its budget-friendly price and satisfactory performance.

Avocado Green Mattress

The Avocado Green Mattress brand stands out as a top producer of crib mattresses, renowned for its use of GOTS-certified organic materials, dual-firmness construction, and Greenguard GOLD and MADE SAFE certifications. It is handmade in California, ensuring superior craftsmanship and a non-toxic, breathable design. The mattress has received high praise, earning a 4.9 out of 5 rating and being recognized by various media outlets such as Consumer Reports and U.S. News for its quality and eco-friendly features. The organic mattress market, which Avocado is a part of, is expected to grow at a CAGR of 8.2% from 2022 to 2032, reflecting the increasing demand for sustainable and organic products.