Top Picks: Best Brands for Delicious Tikka Masala Sauce

Tikka masala sauce, a harmonious blend of spices and rich, creamy textures, has become a beloved staple in kitchens around the world. This tantalizing sauce's popularity has led to a wide array of brands perfecting their own versions to suit diverse palates. From authentic Indian brands to gourmet international offerings, each brings a unique twist to the classic recipe, ensuring there's a perfect tikka masala sauce for every taste. To discover a curated list of the best brands that have mastered this delectable sauce, continue reading below.

Illustration of tikka masala sauce

Best brands of tikka masala sauce in 2025

Patak's

Patak's is a leading brand in the Indian cuisine market, renowned for its high-quality Tikka Masala sauce. With over £60 million in value sales and a 27.4% value share of the Ambient Indian category, Patak's has established itself as a pioneer in British Indian food for nearly 60 years. The brand's Plant Based range, launched in 2021, includes Tikka Masala sauces that are free from artificial colours, flavours, and preservatives, catering to the growing demand for meat-free and vegan options. These sauces, available in major retailers like Ocado, Sainsbury's, Tesco, and Co-op, offer a delicious and indulgent curry experience with the added heartiness of lentils. Patak's commitment to authentic Indian flavours and convenient culinary solutions has made it a favourite among consumers.

Sharwood's

Sharwood's is a leading brand in the Indian food market, particularly renowned for its high-quality tikka masala sauce. The brand, part of Centura Foods, dominates the non-ready meal Indian food category, with Sharwood's and Patak's combined accounting for more than half of the market by value. Sharwood's has innovated with products like the Balanced Living range and recently introduced two-step curry kits to cater to less confident cooks, despite a 19.2% decline in cooking sauce sales in 2023. The brand's commitment to regular product development and significant marketing spend, such as a PS6.5m campaign in 2005, underscores its market leadership. Sharwood's tikka masala sauce is a classic blend of tomatoes, yogurt, and cream, making it a favorite among consumers.

Seeds of Change

Seeds of Change is renowned for its high-quality Tikka Masala Simmer Sauce, offering a convenient and flavorful way to prepare Indian-inspired meals. This sauce, available in an 8.0oz package, is praised for its balanced blend of masala spices without excessive heat. It is a popular choice for those looking to add an Indian accent to their meals, simply by combining it with basmati rice and their favorite protein. The sauce is widely available at various grocery stores, including Walmart and Sendik's Food Market. With its ease of use and delicious flavor, Seeds of Change Tikka Masala Simmer Sauce has become a favorite among many home cooks.

Maya Kaimal

Maya Kaimal is renowned for producing one of the best store-bought tikka masala sauces, praised for its rich, balanced flavor profile and perfect consistency. This sauce stands out with its vibrant, dark orange color and a well-balanced mix of spices, including garam masala, cumin, cinnamon, and clove. It is made with high-quality ingredients such as tomato paste, buttermilk, and unsalted butter, ensuring an authentic and homemade taste. Founder Maya Kaimal's background in Indian cooking and her award-winning book "Curried Flavors" contribute to the sauce's authenticity. Ranked as the top tikka masala sauce in several reviews, it is a favorite among those seeking a quick and delicious Indian dinner.

Stonewall Kitchen

Stonewall Kitchen is renowned for its high-quality Tikka Masala Simmering Sauce, made with ingredients like vine-ripened California tomatoes, heavy cream, and a blend of spices. This sauce, part of their extensive range of gourmet products, serves 4-6 people per 18 oz jar. The company's attention to detail and use of non-genetically modified ingredients make their Tikka Masala sauce a favorite among consumers. With a strong presence in the US market, Stonewall Kitchen contributes to the $31.5 billion sauces, dips, and condiments market, where sauces like theirs hold a significant 44.4% market share.

Trader Joe's

Trader Joe's stands out as a top producer of tikka masala sauce, offering a vegan version that replaces a previously dairy-based formula, making it accessible to a broader audience. This sauce is notable for its creamy yet light texture, rich tomato flavor, and mild heat, suitable for those sensitive to spice. Priced at $2.99, it provides excellent value, especially when stretched into multiple meals with added vegetables and protein. The sauce contains 180 calories per 125g serving and is free from coconut, a significant advantage for those with dietary restrictions. Its aroma and flavor profile closely match traditional tikka masala, making it a popular choice among consumers.

Target's Good & Gather

Target's Good & Gather brand stands out as one of the best producers of tikka masala sauce, praised for its vibrant orange-reddish color, balanced aroma, and light, pleasant flavor. This sauce, available at an affordable price, is noted for its loose, fluid consistency and the well-blended mix of spices, including coconut milk that adds richness without being overpowering. It is the lowest-priced option on the list yet offers a taste similar to what you would find at Indian restaurants in the U.S. The sauce is highly recommended for a quick and tasty Indian dinner at home. Ranked highly in a 2024 taste test, it is a top choice for those seeking an authentic tikka masala experience.

Saffron Road

Saffron Road is renowned for its high-quality, all-natural Tikka Masala simmer sauce, which is certified Halal, gluten-free, and contains no MSG. This sauce, available in 7 oz pouches, offers a medium heat level and authentic Indian flavors, allowing users to prepare world-class cuisine in minutes. With only 40 calories per serving and 16% of the daily sodium value, it is a healthy and flavorful option. Introduced in 2013, these simmer sauces have been praised for their ease of use and rich flavor, making them perfect for busy nights. The sauce is versatile and can be used with chicken, tofu, or vegetables.

Tiger Tiger

Tiger Tiger is highly regarded as one of the best producers of tikka masala sauce, known for its rich and authentic flavor profile. This brand's sauce combines cream with a special blend of herbs and spices, making it a favorite among those seeking a restaurant-quality taste at home. The Peshwari Chicken Tikka Simmer Sauce, for example, contains 221 calories per 1/3 jar, with 70% of those calories coming from fat and 27% from carbs. The sauce is also praised for its ease of use and high-quality ingredients, making it a staple in many kitchens. It has been compared favorably to other brands, including Aldi's Journey to India Tikka Masala, which was noted for its exceptional flavor but is no longer available in its original form.

Campbell's Simmer Sauces

Campbell's, through its diverse product portfolio, does not specifically highlight a brand named "Simmer Sauces" as a leading producer of tikka masala sauce. However, Campbell's is known for its robust sauce offerings, including Prego and now Rao's, which are market leaders in their respective categories. Rao's, acquired by Campbell's, has seen significant growth with a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 33% between 2017 and 2022 in the ultra distinctive Italian sauces category. While Campbell's does offer various cooking sauces, the specific focus on tikka masala sauce is not prominently featured. The company's sauces segment, including brands like Prego and Rao's, contributes significantly to its revenue, with Rao's generating $878.4 million in net sales in 2022.