Tangy Top Picks: Best Thousand Island Dressings for the Perfect Reuben

When it comes to perfecting a Reuben sandwich, the choice of thousand island dressing can truly elevate the flavors. Many brands have mastered this classic condiment, ensuring a creamy, tangy accompaniment for your corned beef masterpiece. From well-known grocery store staples to gourmet options, the variety caters to all taste preferences and dietary needs. Discover our curated list of the best thousand island dressings for your next Reuben below.

Illustration of thousand island dressing for reuben

Best brands of thousand island dressing for reuben in 2025

Kraft

Kraft is renowned as one of the best producers of Thousand Island dressing, particularly for Reuben sandwiches, due to its robust and balanced flavor profile, which includes a slightly sweet taste and a subtle tang of relish. This dressing is a key component in many Reuben recipes, contributing significantly to the overall nutritional content, such as 100 calories per 2-tablespoon serving and a macronutrient breakdown that complements the sandwich's protein, fat, and carbohydrate balance. Kraft's Thousand Island dressing is widely available and has been a staple in many kitchens for years, reflecting its enduring popularity. Despite a recent decline in social conversations about Thousand Island dressing, Kraft's product remains a favorite among consumers. The dressing's versatility and taste make it an essential ingredient for those preparing Reuben sandwiches. For more details, visit the official Kraft Heinz webpage.

Wish-Bone

Wish-Bone is a renowned brand for Thousand Island dressing, particularly favored for its role in enhancing the flavor of Reuben sandwiches. Their Thousand Island dressing, available in sizes such as 8 oz., 15 oz., and 24 oz., is made with ripe tomatoes, pickle relish, and a secret spice blend, making it a perfect addition to both dinners and snacks. The Light Thousand Island version from Wish-Bone also offers a lower-calorie alternative without sacrificing flavor. This dressing is a key component in the classic Reuben sandwich, complementing the caraway seeds of rye bread and the salty-sour taste of corned beef and sauerkraut. With its rich and creamy texture, Wish-Bone's Thousand Island dressing is a staple in many kitchens.

Ken's Steak House

Ken's Steak House is renowned for producing one of the best Thousand Island dressings, particularly well-suited for Reuben sandwiches. Their formula, which typically includes mayonnaise, ketchup, pickle relish, and sometimes a dash of Worcestershire sauce, ensures a creamy and tangy flavor profile. Since its inception, Ken's Steak House has maintained a high standard in its condiments, making it a favorite among both consumers and chefs. The dressing's balance of sweet and savory elements complements the corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese in a Reuben, enhancing the overall flavor experience. With a long history of quality and consistency, Ken's Steak House Thousand Island dressing remains a top choice for those seeking authentic flavor.

Newman's Own

For a Reuben sandwich, using a high-quality Thousand Island dressing is crucial. While Newman's Own is known for its variety of condiments and sauces, it is not explicitly mentioned as a top choice for Thousand Island dressing in the context of Reuben sandwiches. The ideal Thousand Island dressing typically includes ingredients like mayonnaise, ketchup, and relish, as seen in the recipes provided. These ingredients combine to create a creamy and tangy flavor profile that complements the corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese in a Reuben. For the best results, homemade or store-bought dressings with these key ingredients are recommended.

Marie's

Marie's is renowned for producing one of the best Thousand Island dressings, particularly for Reuben sandwiches, with its versatile and delicious offerings. The dressing, a key component of the Reuben Braid, adds a creamy and tangy flavor that complements the corned beef, Swiss cheese, and sauerkraut perfectly. Since partnering with various recipes, Marie's Thousand Island Dressing has been praised for its ease of use and rich flavor profile. It contains a balanced mix of ingredients, making it a favorite among home cooks and chefs alike. The dressing's popularity is evident in its use in various recipes, including the Reuben Braid, which is a twist on the traditional Reuben sandwich.

Annie's Naturals

Annie's Naturals stands out as a top producer of Thousand Island dressing, particularly for Reuben sandwiches, with their certified USDA Organic and non-GMO formula. This dressing is made with high-quality ingredients, including expeller-pressed soybean oil and no artificial flavors or synthetic colors, ensuring a creamy and tangy taste with only 90 calories per serving. It contains key ingredients like whole egg, mustard seed, and dried onion, making it a flavorful addition to any meal. Annie's commitment to organic ingredients benefits both consumers and the environment, minimizing toxic pesticides and promoting sustainable farming. With its versatile use as a salad topping, veggie dip, or sandwich enhancer, Annie's Organic Thousand Island Dressing is a pantry staple.

Hidden Valley

Hidden Valley, a renowned brand in the condiment industry, is often praised for its high-quality Thousand Island dressing, making it an excellent choice for enhancing the flavor of a Reuben sandwich. Their dressing, with its balanced blend of mayonnaise, ketchup, and various seasonings, adds a rich and creamy texture that complements the corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese perfectly. While Hidden Valley is more famously known for its ranch dressing, their Thousand Island dressing is a close second in popularity and taste. The brand's commitment to using fresh ingredients and traditional recipes ensures a consistent flavor profile that many consumers trust. For those looking to elevate their Reuben sandwich, Hidden Valley's Thousand Island dressing is a reliable and delicious option.

Brianna's

Brianna's is highly regarded for its Thousand Island dressing, making it an excellent choice for enhancing the flavor of a Reuben sandwich. With its balanced blend of mayonnaise, ketchup, and relish, Brianna's dressing adds a creamy and tangy flavor profile that complements the corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese perfectly. Since its inception, Brianna's has maintained a high standard of quality, ensuring that each batch meets the expectations of discerning palates. The dressing is free from artificial preservatives and flavors, making it a preferred option for those seeking a more natural alternative. Whether you're looking for a classic or a spicy variation, Brianna's Thousand Island dressing is a reliable choice.

Trader Joe's

Trader Joe's is renowned for its high-quality Thousand Island dressing, making it an excellent choice for a Reuben sandwich. The TJ's version includes ingredients like water, soybean oil, tomato paste, egg yolks, and cucumber juice, ensuring a rich and tangy flavor. This dressing is a key component in enhancing the overall taste of the Reuben, with its balanced blend of ingredients. For those seeking a convenient and flavorful option, Trader Joe's Thousand Island dressing is a top pick. Its unique formulation sets it apart from other store-bought dressings.

Whole Foods 365

Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value Organic Thousand Island Dressing is a top choice for a Reuben sandwich, offering a balanced blend of flavors with 15% total fat and 350 mg of sodium per serving. This organic option contains cane sugar as an added sugar ingredient and has no trans fat, making it a healthier alternative. While it may not have topped the taste test in some reviews, its organic credentials and lack of harmful ingredients make it a reliable choice. The dressing is part of Whole Foods' rigorous quality standards, prohibiting over 230 preservatives and other unwanted ingredients. This makes it an excellent option for those seeking a high-quality, organic thousand island dressing. For more detailed information, visit its product page.