Top Pie Crust Brands: A Tasty Crust Comparison Guide

When it comes to crafting the perfect pie, the crust can often make or break your dessert experience. From buttery, flaky textures to those that offer a hint of sweetness, choosing the right pie crust brand is essential for bakers of all levels. With so many options on the market, it's important to know which brands deliver consistently impressive results and enhance your favorite fillings. Whether you prefer a classic homemade feel or a convenient ready-made option, discover some of the best brands for pie crusts that promise to elevate your baking endeavors in the list below.

Illustration of pie crust

Best brands of pie crust in 2025

Pillsbury

Pillsbury is a leading brand in the pie crust market, known for its convenient and delicious refrigerated pie crusts that offer homemade taste without the hassle. These crusts are ideal for making various pies, including seasonal favorites like apple cinnamon, pecan, and pumpkin, and can be easily unrolled, filled, and baked. Pillsbury refrigerated pie crusts are a popular choice, contributing to the growth of the global pie shells market, which is expected to witness healthy growth driven by increasing demand for convenience foods. The brand's products are widely available in retail stores and online, catering to the rising consumer preference for ready-to-bake goods. With its versatile and easy-to-use pie crusts, Pillsbury continues to be a favorite among consumers.

Marie Callender's

Marie Callender's is a leading brand in the frozen pie crust market, known for its high-quality and convenient products. The brand, managed by ConAgra Foods since the acquisition of American Pie, LLC in 2010, has seen significant growth, with Marie Callender's frozen dessert sales increasing by 42% over five years according to IRI data. Marie Callender's pie crusts are popular for their ease of use and homemade taste, contributing to the brand's strong equity with consumers. The global frozen pie crusts market, which includes Marie Callender's products, is projected to grow at a CAGR of approximately 4.3% during the forecast period. This growth is driven by the increasing demand for fast and simple meal solutions. For more about their Pastry Pie Shells, explore their website.

Trader Joe's

Trader Joe's stands out as one of the best producers of pie crusts, praised for its delicious and affordable offerings. Their pie crust, available for just $4.49, is noted for its crisp and flaky texture, pleasant buttery flavor, and good structural integrity, making it a favorite among bakers. It contains both butter and shortening, lacks preservatives and other unwanted additives, and performs well even when prepared a day in advance. This crust has been highly recommended in taste tests, highlighting its balance of flavor and texture. With its convenience and quality, Trader Joe's pie crust is a top choice for home bakers.

Wholly Wholesome

Wholly Wholesome is a leading brand in the production of high-quality, allergy-friendly pie crusts, having launched their Wholly Gluten Free line in 2014 to cater to consumers with gluten intolerance and other allergies. Their gluten-free pie shells are made in a segregated, cross-contamination-free environment and have gained significant popularity, contributing to the company's triple-digit growth during the COVID-19 pandemic. The brand's commitment to natural ingredients and efficient production has enabled them to expand their facilities multiple times, including moving to a 35,000-square foot site. Wholly Wholesome's products are free from common allergens such as dairy, eggs, soy, and nuts, making them accessible to a wide range of consumers. Their success is reflected in their rapid sales benchmarks, achieving in 12 months what typically takes 36 months. You can find more information about their gluten-free pie crust on their website.

Immaculate Baking

Immaculate Baking is a renowned brand in the pie crust market, known for its wholesome ingredients and ease of use. Their pie crusts are perfect for desserts, quiches, pot pies, and turnovers, and are made without chemical softeners, ensuring a natural and healthy baking experience. Each serving of their pie crust contains 120 calories, 7g of total fat, and 12g of total carbohydrates, making it a balanced choice for consumers. The crusts are available in convenient packaging, with 16 servings per container, and can be baked at 400 degrees F for 11-13 minutes. Immaculate Baking's commitment to quality and natural ingredients has made it a favorite among consumers looking for a reliable and healthy pie crust option. For more details, visit their official product page.

Tenderflake

Tenderflake is a renowned brand in the baking industry, particularly celebrated for its high-quality pie crusts that have been a staple in Canadian baking for over 70 years. The brand's lard, which is non-hydrogenated, is crafted through a traditional rendering process that ensures a light and flaky crust. The classic Tenderflake recipe, found on the side of their boxes, yields enough dough for 3 double-crust pies or 6 single pie shells, using 5 1/2 cups of all-purpose flour and 1 pound of Tenderflake lard. This recipe has been trusted by generations of bakers for its consistency and flavor. Despite some users noting recent variations in texture, the traditional process of Tenderflake lard has remained unchanged. For detailed instructions, check the Tenderflake recipe online.

Great Value

Great Value, a brand by Walmart, stands out as one of the best producers of pie crusts due to its consistent quality and performance. The Great Value Deep Dish Pie Crusts are particularly praised for retaining their shape and providing a buttery, flaky texture, making them ideal for both sweet and savory pies. These crusts are also notable for having no trans fat or cholesterol, offering a healthier option for homemade delights. With each pack including two 9-inch crusts, they are versatile and convenient for various baking needs. The brand's commitment to quality is evident in its structural integrity and flavor, making it a top choice among consumers.

Ready Pie Crust by Keebler

Keebler's Ready Crust is a leading brand in the pie crust market, offering convenient and high-quality pre-made pie crusts that save time and reduce labor costs. Available in various flavors such as graham cracker and shortbread, these crusts are perfect for both commercial and residential baking needs. With a crispy texture and delicious flavor, Keebler's Ready Crust enhances any pie or tart filling. The brand, part of the Kellogg Company, has been a trusted name since 1853, and its products are widely used in bakeries, restaurants, and homes. The global frozen pie crusts market, which includes Keebler's products, is projected to grow at a CAGR of 5.36% to reach USD 1.90 billion by 2030.

Oronoque Orchards

Oronoque Orchards is renowned for producing high-quality pie crusts, making it a favorite among East Coast families. Their Deep Dish Pie Crusts are convenient and ready-made, perfect for various fillings such as quiches, pumpkin pies, and pecan pies. To achieve the best results, users can follow the simple baking instructions provided, including preheating the oven to 375°F and baking the crust for 12-15 minutes. The crusts are made from ingredients like wheat flour, palm oil, and sugar, ensuring a delicious and crispy texture. For a crisper crust, preheating the baking sheet in the oven is recommended.

King Arthur Baking Company

King Arthur Baking Company is renowned for its high-quality baking products, including its Double Pie Crust Mix, which ensures a flaky, buttery pie crust every time. Founded in 1790, the company is the oldest flour company in the United States and saw a significant surge in sales during the COVID-19 pandemic, with flour sales increasing by twenty times in March 2020. Their mixes are crafted with simple, non-GMO ingredients and no artificial colors or flavors. The company's rebranding in 2020 aimed to attract a broader audience, emphasizing joy and inclusivity in baking. With a strong commitment to quality and customer support, King Arthur Baking Company remains a trusted name for bakers.