Top Simple Syrup Brands for Crafting the Perfect Old Fashioned

Crafting the perfect Old Fashioned cocktail requires not just skill but also the finest ingredients, starting with the ever-essential simple syrup. The market is flooded with numerous brands, but only a select few stand out for their quality and flavor profile that complements the classic drink impeccably. From small-batch artisanal makers to renowned brands recognized for their consistent excellence, there are several options to elevate your cocktail experience. To help you find the best fit for your Old Fashioned, explore the curated list of top simple syrup brands below.

Illustration of simple syrup for old fashioned

Best brands of simple syrup for old fashioned in 2025

Liber & Co. Classic Gum Syrup

Liber & Co. is renowned for its high-quality Classic Gum Syrup, which is a key component in their Old Fashioned Cocktail Syrup. This syrup combines rich and silky gum syrup with aromatic bitters and cold-pressed orange oil, allowing for a perfectly balanced Old Fashioned every time. A single 9.5 oz bottle can yield up to 38 Old Fashioneds, making it a great value for hosting or gifting. The syrup has a 24-month shelf life and remains fresh for at least 12 months after opening when stored in the fridge. It is crafted using premium raw sugar crystals refined from sugarcane, primarily grown in Florida and Louisiana.

Simple Times Mixers Classic Simple Syrup

Simple Times Mixers is not specifically known for a classic simple syrup for old fashioned cocktails, but they do offer high-quality, all-natural mixers. For an old fashioned, you might prefer a syrup with ingredients like brown sugar, orange extract, and bitters, such as those found in other brands. However, Simple Times Mixers excels in other flavors like their Strawberry Sage Margarita mixer, which contains 34% juice and is gluten-free and vegan. Their mixers are made in Columbus, OH, and have a 9-month shelf life. Each 32oz bottle makes 8-10 cocktails.

Eli Mason Old Fashioned Cocktail Mixer

Eli Mason's Old Fashioned Cocktail Mixer is a top choice for crafting authentic Old Fashioned cocktails, made with handcrafted, all-natural ingredients like real cane sugar and a proprietary blend of premium bitters. This mixer, produced in small batches in Nashville, Tennessee, incorporates organic gum arabic for a luxurious, velvet-smooth texture. Each 10oz bottle yields over 20 generous servings, and the product has a shelf life of 24-36 months. Eli Mason's mixer is non-alcoholic and can be easily combined with bourbon or whiskey for a consistent, delicious Old Fashioned every time. This convenient mixer saves time and effort, making it ideal for both home enthusiasts and professional bartenders. You can explore more about the Eli Mason's Old Fashioned Cocktail Mixer on the Triangle Wine Co's website.

Sonoma Syrup Co. Classic Simple Syrup

Sonoma Syrup Co.'s Classic Simple Syrup is a top choice for mixologists and home bartenders alike, particularly for crafting an unforgettable Old Fashioned cocktail. This syrup, infused with a hint of vanilla, is made from pure cane sugar and filtered water, ensuring a rich and smooth flavor. Introduced in the first American cookbook in 1796, simple syrup has been a staple ingredient, and Sonoma Syrup Co.'s version is favored for its lack of artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. It is Non-GMO Project Verified and handcrafted in small batches in the USA. This syrup is versatile, suitable for cocktails, iced tea, and baked goods. You can explore further details on their Classic Simple Syrup.

Stirrings Simple Syrup

Stirrings Simple Syrup is a premium choice for crafting exceptional old fashioned cocktails, made with pure cane sugar and triple-filtered water, ensuring a subtle yet classic flavor. Each serving size of 1 FL OZ (30ml) contains 50 calories and 14g of carbohydrates, with 28% of the daily value of sugars. This syrup is hassle-free and easy to use, perfect for both alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinks. With about 12 servings per container, it is a great addition to any home bar. Stirrings Simple Syrup is ready to ship within 24-48 hours and typically delivers within 3-7 business days.

Fee Brothers Simple Syrup

Fee Brothers is renowned for its high-quality simple syrups, particularly suited for crafting exceptional Old Fashioned cocktails. Their syrups, available in various flavors, are designed to add depth and complexity to mixology, with a rich history spanning over five generations. For an Old Fashioned, using 2 teaspoons of simple syrup, such as one made with turbinado sugar, is often recommended for optimal balance. Fee Brothers' syrups are versatile and can be used in a variety of drinks, from cocktails to mocktails, and even in food and condiments. Their aromatic bitters, like the Fee Brothers Aromatic Bitters, are particularly noted for their cinnamon flavor, which complements the bourbon in an Old Fashioned perfectly.

Giffard Sirop de Sucre de Canne

Giffard Sirop de Sucre de Canne emerges as a premier choice for simple syrup in Old Fashioned cocktails, offering a pure sugar syrup crafted from unrefined brown sugar cane without any preservatives. This syrup is enriched with flavors of honey, vanilla, and slight caramelized notes, making it an essential ingredient for professional bartenders. Each 100ml serving provides 356 kcal, containing 89g of carbohydrates and sugars. Giffard syrups are pasteurized to ensure perfect preservation and are designed for versatile use in both alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages. With its high-quality composition and absence of preservatives, Giffard Sirop de Sucre de Canne is ideal for crafting authentic Old Fashioned cocktails.

Monin Pure Cane Syrup

Monin Pure Cane Syrup, produced by the renowned French company Monin since 1912, is a high-quality simple syrup ideal for old fashioned cocktails. It dissolves instantly in both hot and cold beverages, offering great versatility. This syrup is made from natural ingredients and is available in a 750ml bottle, with the option to buy in bulk for a 5% discount. Monin's global presence spans 140 countries, ensuring a consistent and authentic flavor experience. The syrup's convenience and quality make it a favorite among bartenders and home mixologists.

W&P Craft Cocktail Syrup

W&P Craft Cocktail Syrup is a top choice for crafting exceptional Old Fashioned cocktails, made with premium, small-batch ingredients like Demerara cane sugar, bitters, and natural flavors. This syrup, produced in the USA, allows for easy mixing with just 1/2 oz syrup and 2 oz whiskey, ensuring a bartender-worthy drink. With a recipe that has been praised by users for over 4-5 years, it stands out for its simplicity and flavor. Each 1 oz of the syrup can make two drinks, making it a convenient option. The syrup is part of a collection that includes other popular cocktail flavors like Moscow Mule and Light Margarita. For a closer look at their diverse offerings, check out the DIY Craft Cocktail Syrup collection.

Proof Old Fashioned Syrup

Proof Old Fashioned Syrup, originating from a craft cocktail bar in Decatur, Georgia, is a top choice for simplifying the process of making old fashioneds at home. Since its inception in 2014, the brand has expanded to offer over 20 flavors, including Traditional, Maple Bacon, and Pecan, all made with premium ingredients like organic cane sugar, real citrus oils, and high-quality aromatic bitters. The syrups are handcrafted in small batches in Atlanta, Georgia, ensuring consistent quality. To make an old fashioned, users simply mix 0.5 oz of Proof Syrup with 2 oz of their favorite bourbon or rye whiskey. This "everything but the bourbon" approach has made Proof Syrup a favorite among home bartenders. Discover more about their Traditional Proof Syrup.