Top Pepper Jelly Brands That Spice Up Your Pantry Delightfully!

Pepper jelly, a delightful blend of sweet and spicy flavors, has become a staple in many households, offering a unique twist to traditional spreads and condiments. Whether you're looking to spice up your breakfast toast or add a kick to your cheese platter, choosing the right brand can make all the difference. In this article, we explore some of the best brands that have mastered the art of crafting delicious pepper jelly, each offering their own distinct taste and texture. Ready to elevate your flavor game? Discover our top picks below.

Illustration of pepper jelly

Best brands of pepper jelly in 2025

Braswell's

Braswell's is renowned as one of the best producers of pepper jelly, with their Red Pepper Jelly being a top-selling product in the US. Founded in 1946 by Albert Braswell, the company uses small-batch cooking methods and premium ingredients, including cane sugar, red bell peppers, and apple cider vinegar. This versatile jelly is popular for its use as a hors d'oeuvre with cream cheese and crackers, as a glaze for meats, and as a side dish with baby carrots. With a carbohydrate content of 60g per serving and no dietary fiber, it is a favorite among foodies and home cooks alike. Braswell's Red Pepper Jelly has garnered numerous positive reviews for its delicious flavor and ease of use.

Stonewall Kitchen

Stonewall Kitchen is renowned for its high-quality pepper jellies, particularly its top-selling Red Pepper Jelly, which combines flavorful sweet red peppers, sugar, and a dash of cayenne pepper. Made in the USA, this jelly is a versatile pantry staple ideal for burgers, sandwiches, and cheese boards. With over 30 years of commitment to quality, Stonewall Kitchen crafts its products in small batches to ensure every spoonful bursts with delicious flavor. Their pepper jellies are non-gluten and free from genetically modified ingredients, making them a favorite among various palates. The brand's dedication to using the freshest ingredients has made their jams and jellies pantry staples for decades.

Tabasco

Tabasco brand is renowned for producing some of the best pepper jellies, offering a perfect blend of spicy and sweet flavors. Their pepper jellies, available in spicy or mild jalapeno versions, are made with high-quality ingredients like green bell peppers, jalapeno peppers, and apple juice, ensuring a unique taste experience. Since the late 1970s, when pepper jelly first gained popularity, Tabasco has maintained its reputation by using aged pepper mash and a proprietary blend of spices. Each 10 oz jar contains 40 calories per tablespoon and is ideal for serving with cream cheese and crackers or as a glaze for roasted meats. The company's commitment to quality and tradition, as seen in their fifth-generation family ownership, contributes to their enduring success. Discover more about their Tabasco Mild Pepper Jelly.

Terrapin Ridge Farms

Terrapin Ridge Farms is renowned for its high-quality, all-natural gourmet products, including its popular Hot Pepper Bacon Jam, which has garnered rave reviews for its unique and flavorful combinations. The company has been recognized as one of the fastest-growing private companies in America, ranking No. 3472 on the Inc. 5000 list in 2022. Customers praise the products for their taste and quality, with many favorites like the Raspberry Amaretto Jam and Blueberry Bourbon Pecan Jam. Terrapin Ridge Farms offers significant discounts during events like Black Friday, with up to 70% off on various products. The company is committed to customer satisfaction, providing fast shipping and responsive customer service.

American Spoon

American Spoon is renowned for its high-quality pepper jelly, crafted in small batches in their Petoskey, Michigan kitchen using traditional techniques and premium ingredients like Michigan apple cider. Their Jalapeno Pepper Jelly, made in copper kettles, combines the mild heat of jalapenos with the subtle sweetness of apple cider, creating a complex and savory flavor profile. With a focus on capturing peak flavors and textures, American Spoon's products are a staple in many Midwestern pantries. The brand's commitment to quality is evident in their meticulous production process, involving a dozen skilled individuals to produce each jar. American Spoon's products are made in limited quantities, such as 80 jars at a time for their Chili Jam, ensuring consistency and excellence.

Trappist Preserves

Trappist Preserves, produced by the Trappist Monks of St. Joseph's Abbey in Spencer, Massachusetts since 1954, is renowned for its high-quality, all-natural preserves, jams, jellies, and conserves. Although they are not specifically known for pepper jelly, their products are celebrated for superior flavor, vibrant color, and the absence of artificial coloring, flavors, or preservatives. The monks' dedication to using fresh ingredients and traditional methods has made Trappist Preserves a premier brand in North America. With over 30 flavors available, their products are a testament to the monks' commitment to excellence and hospitality. Since its inception, Trappist Preserves has maintained a strong reputation for quality and natural ingredients. For more information on their products, visit their official website.

Robert Rothschild Farm

Robert Rothschild Farm is renowned for its high-quality gourmet preserves, particularly its Red Pepper Jelly, which is all natural and gluten-free. This product features a full-bodied blend of red and jalapeno peppers, complemented by vinegar and sugar. The jelly is part of a range that has garnered praise for its rich flavor profiles. Each serving contains a balanced mix of ingredients, although it is noteworthy that some products from the brand can be high in sugar, with some containing up to 50% sugar by weight. The brand's commitment to quality and natural ingredients makes it a favorite among those seeking gourmet condiments.

Fischer & Wieser

Fischer & Wieser is renowned as one of the best producers of pepper jelly, offering a variety of flavors that cater to different palates. With over 55 years of experience, the company has crafted hundreds of gourmet recipes, including their popular Mild Green Jalapeno Jelly and Red Jalapeno Jelly. Their products, such as the Mild Green Jalapeno Jelly, are made with high-quality ingredients like sugar, apple cider vinegar, and jalapenos, and are manufactured in a facility that adheres to strict quality standards. The company's commitment to quality is reflected in their customer reviews, with products like the Original Roasted Raspberry Chipotle Sauce garnering awards and accolades globally. Fischer & Wieser's products are available in various quantities, with discounts offered for bulk purchases, such as 6.71% off for orders of 12 or more items.

Mrs. Mason's Co.

Mrs. G's Hot Pepper Jellies, a brand under Mrs. G's company, is renowned for its high-quality pepper jelly. Having started in the early 1980s and gaining significant popularity by 2013, the company was founded by Cindy Greaver. It has expanded its operations to partner with a 4th generation local co-packer to meet the increasing demand, ensuring the jellies are made according to Cindy's original recipes. With over a decade in business, Mrs. G's has established itself as a trusted name in artisanal jellies, particularly in the Temecula, CA area. The company's commitment to using fresh, locally sourced peppers has contributed to its success, making it a favorite among both local and wider audiences. Mrs. G's jellies are now available in various retail outlets and online.

Pepper Creek Farms

Pepper Creek Farms is renowned for its high-quality pepper jelly, offering a unique blend of flavors that combine the sweetness of pure cane sugar with the tangy heat of fresh jalapeno and bell peppers. Their Mint Pepper Jelly, in particular, stands out with its refreshing twist of natural mint flavor, making it a favorite for serving on cream cheese and crackers or as a complement to leg of lamb. With a careful balance of ingredients, including white wine vinegar and pectin, Pepper Creek Farms ensures a consistent and delicious product. The brand's attention to detail and commitment to using fresh ingredients have earned it a loyal customer base. For those looking for a slightly spicy yet sweet condiment, Pepper Creek Farms' pepper jelly is an excellent choice.