Top Buffalo Sauce Brands for a Fiery Kick!

Buffalo sauce has become a beloved staple in many kitchens, elevating everything from wings to vegetables with its tangy and spicy kick. With a range of brands offering their unique twists on this classic condiment, it's worth exploring the best options available to enhance your culinary creations. Whether you crave a milder flavor or an intensely hot blend, there is a buffalo sauce out there to match your taste preferences. To discover some of the top brands that have mastered the art of crafting this fiery favorite, look below.

Illustration of buffalo sauce

Best brands of buffalo sauce in 2025

Frank's RedHot

Frank's RedHot is a leading brand in the hot sauce market, particularly renowned for its role in the creation of Buffalo chicken wings. It was the secret ingredient in the original Buffalo chicken wing sauce recipe developed at the Anchor Bar in Buffalo, NY in 1964. Frank's RedHot holds the number one position in the US and Canada, with a market share approximately twice that of its next largest competitor. The brand is highly favored among millennials, with 80% of them viewing McCormick spices, including Frank's RedHot, as the best or one of the best. Its global ambitions include making Frank's the number one hot sauce worldwide, leveraging the growing demand in the hot sauce category. Discover more about Frank's RedHot Buffalo Wings Sauce.

Crystal

Crystal Hot Sauce is a notable producer in the hot sauce market, known for its versatile and moderately spicy options. The brand generates revenue between $10 million to $15 million as of September 2024 and attracts around 12,800 visits to its website over the last three months. Crystal Hot Sauce is favored for its thinner consistency, making it ideal for mixing into sauces or applying thinly, and it is often compared to other popular brands like Frank's RedHot in terms of usage and preference. The global hot sauce market, which includes Crystal Hot Sauce, is expected to grow at a CAGR of 4.2% from 2024 to 2031, reaching a market size of $16,647 million by 2031. Crystal Hot Sauce is among the key players in this expanding market.

Primal Kitchen

Primal Kitchen is renowned for producing one of the best buffalo sauces, particularly its Hot Buffalo Sauce, which is made with high-quality ingredients like avocado oil and red cayenne peppers. This sauce is vegan, Keto Certified, Certified Paleo, and Whole30 Approved, making it a versatile option for various dietary needs. It contains 25 calories per serving, with 19% of the daily value of sodium and 3% of total fat. Primal Kitchen's buffalo sauce has won a NEXTY Award in 2020, highlighting its innovation and quality. The brand's commitment to using real, delicious ingredients has made its products, including the buffalo sauce, top-sellers and consumer favorites.

Noble Made by The New Primal

Noble Made by The New Primal is a reputable brand known for its high-quality buffalo sauces, offering products that are Whole30 Approved, Certified Paleo, and Certified Gluten-Free. Their Hot Buffalo Sauce is made with ingredients like cayenne peppers, distilled vinegar, and extra virgin olive oil, ensuring a flavorful and healthy option. With no added sugar, these sauces cater to various dietary needs, including keto and paleo diets. The brand's commitment to transparency and safety is evident in their rigorous manufacturing processes and clear allergen labeling. Since their brand split in December 2022, Noble Made has enhanced its customer experience with separate websites and optimized shipping prices. Learn more about their mild buffalo sauce.

Sweet Baby Ray's

Sweet Baby Ray's is a leading brand in the barbecue sauce industry, particularly renowned for its buffalo wing sauce. Developed by Chicago brothers Dave and Larry Raymond in the 1980s, the brand has grown significantly since its inception, with Sweet Baby Ray's becoming the best-selling barbecue sauce in the U.S., capturing over 48% of consumer preference in a 2022 survey. The brand was sold to Ken's Foods in 2005 for $30 million and has since expanded to a $600 million brand. Sweet Baby Ray's offers a variety of flavors, including the popular Original and Sweet & Spicy, and has introduced a no sugar added line of sauces. The buffalo wing sauce, made with aged cayenne pepper and a buttery finish, is a classic favorite among consumers.

Texas Pete

Texas Pete is a leading brand in the hot sauce market, particularly renowned for its Buffalo Wing Sauce, which offers a bold and spicy flavor profile. It is the number one hot sauce brand in the U.S. in sales of hot sauce portion control packets, with 65% of consumers expressing their love for hot sauce, and younger demographics such as Gen Z, Millennials, and Gen X showing even higher preferences. The brand's Buffalo Wing Sauce is made with ingredients like aged peppers, vinegar, and natural butter type flavor, and is manufactured on a line that also produces soy products. Texas Pete's hot sauces are favored by various consumer groups, including African Americans and Hispanics, and the brand has seen significant growth in sales to convenience store operators. With its wide range of flavors and heat levels, Texas Pete continues to be a go-to choice for adding spicy goodness to menu items.

Buffalo Wild Wings

Buffalo Wild Wings is a leading brand in the sports bar category, renowned for its signature buffalo sauce and extensive menu of chicken wings. The company, with over 1,242 locations in the U.S., generated $3.937 billion in sales in 2022. To enhance their beer experience, Buffalo Wild Wings implemented a real-time inventory management system, reducing beer shrinkage by double digits and increasing revenue from beer sales. Their successful promotions, such as the $19.99 all-you-can-eat deal, have significantly boosted weekday foot traffic, with visits increasing by up to 73.9% on certain days. The brand's commitment to quality and innovation has solidified its position as a top choice for buffalo wing enthusiasts. For more information, visit their official website.

Cholula

Cholula, though not specifically known for buffalo sauce, is a prominent brand in the hot sauce market, acquired by McCormick & Company in an $800 million deal in 2020. Cholula's annual net sales are approximately $96 million, and the brand is expected to grow at a rate of mid-to-high single digits beyond the COVID-19 pandemic. It is part of a hot sauce empire that, combined with Frank's RedHot, makes up about 30% of the US hot sauce market. Cholula's sales surged 24.6% in the twelve months ending November 7, 2020, reflecting the category's average annual growth of 9.7% over the past four years. The brand is known for its authentic, bold, and spicy Mexican flavors.

Red Duck

Red Duck, a brand under Beaverton Foods, is renowned for its high-quality condiments, although it does not specifically produce buffalo sauce. However, Red Duck's expertise in crafting flavorful and balanced sauces, such as their Hot Honey Chipotle BBQ Sauce, demonstrates their capability in creating spicy and tangy condiments. This sauce, made with organic ingredients and featuring a blend of smoked chipotle peppers, honey, and rich coffee, showcases the brand's attention to detail and flavor profiling. While Red Duck does not offer a traditional buffalo sauce, their product range highlights their commitment to using organic ingredients and innovative flavor combinations. Beaverton Foods, the parent company, has a rich history dating back to 1929 and is known as the largest specialty condiment manufacturer in the United States.

Anchor Bar

Anchor Bar is renowned as one of the best producers of buffalo sauce, tracing its origins back to 1964 when Teressa Bellissimo created the first Buffalo wings at the family-owned Anchor Bar in Buffalo, New York. This iconic buffalo sauce, a blend of hot sauce, butter, and other secret ingredients, has become a staple in American cuisine, with Americans consuming over 1.45 billion chicken wings annually, many of which are flavored with Anchor Bar's signature sauce. The sauce is available in various flavors, including Medium, Hotter, Mild, Extreme Heat, and Spicy Barbecue, catering to different taste preferences. Anchor Bar's sauce is celebrated for its rich, smooth texture and perfect balance of heat and flavor, making it a favorite among wing enthusiasts. The brand's sauces are widely available, including in 12 oz bottles and larger quantities.