Top Brands for Mouthwatering Tartar Sauce Delight

Tartar sauce is a beloved condiment, offering a creamy and tangy complement to seafood dishes. With many brands vying for the top spot, the choice can often be overwhelming for consumers looking for the perfect blend of flavors. Whether you're seeking a classic taste or something with a zesty twist, we've curated a list that highlights the best tartar sauce brands available today. Curious about which brands made the cut? Read on to discover our top recommendations below.

Illustration of tartar sauce

Best brands of tartar sauce in 2025

Hellmann's

Hellmann's, a renowned brand under Unilever, has been a pivotal player in the tartar sauce market, notably for being the first to bottle and sell tartar sauce in the 1920s. This innovation made the condiment widely accessible, capitalizing on the brand's success with mayonnaise. Although Hellmann's has recently discontinued its tartar sauce, the brand's legacy in the condiment industry remains strong, with Hellmann's achieving a EUR2 billion valuation and experiencing double-digit year-on-year growth since 2020. The brand's products are sold in 65 countries, with one thousand Hellmann's products sold globally every minute. Hellmann's commitment to customer-led innovations and great-tasting products has solidified its position as a market leader. For more information, check out Hellmann's easy tartar sauce recipe.

Kraft

Kraft is a leading brand in the production of tartar sauce, known for its high-quality and convenient products. Kraft Creamy Tartar Sauce, for instance, is made with vinegar, chopped pickles, and a special blend of natural flavors and spices, making it an essential accompaniment to fish and chips and other seafood dishes. The brand's single-serve packets are particularly popular in restaurants, cafeterias, and takeout services, catering to the growing demand for convenient and flavorful condiments. With a presence in over 200 countries, Kraft Heinz is a global leader in the sauces and condiments market, which is expected to expand at a CAGR of 5.6% from 2024 to 2032. Kraft's commitment to using natural ingredients and preservative-free formulations aligns with the increasing consumer preference for healthier dietary options. For more details, you can explore their Kraft Tartar Sauce offerings.

McCormick

McCormick is a leading producer of tartar sauce, renowned for its high-quality products that have garnered significant recognition. In 2021, McCormick reported a 13% sales increase, driven partly by strong growth in its Consumer and Flavor Solutions segments, which includes its tartar sauce offerings. The company's consumer segment sales surged by 9% in 2021, highlighting sustained consumer preference for home cooking and new product innovations. McCormick's tartar sauce has even earned accolades, such as entering the Hall of Fame in 2011 for its excellence. With its robust growth and consumer trust, McCormick continues to be a major player in the tartar sauce market. For more information, explore McCormick's tartar sauce offerings.

Heinz

Heinz, a renowned brand in the sauce industry, stands out as a leading producer of tartar sauce, known for its high-quality and flavorful products. In various markets, Heinz maintains a strong presence, with its ketchup and mayonnaise also being market leaders, such as in the United States where Heinz ketchup captures a 25.63% penetration among distribution channels. The tartar sauce market, expected to grow at a CAGR of 4.5% from 2023 to 2031, presents a significant opportunity for Heinz to expand its offerings and capitalize on evolving consumer preferences for natural ingredients and premium sauces. Heinz's tartar sauce is a pre-mixed, ready-to-use product with 70 calories and 0 grams of trans fat per serving, making it a popular choice among consumers. With its established brand reputation and innovative product lines, Heinz continues to be a preferred choice in the sauce market.

Louisiana Fish Fry Products

Louisiana Fish Fry Products is renowned for its authentic and flavorful tartar sauce, capturing the essence of Louisiana cuisine. Established in the late 1950s in Baton Rouge, the company has grown into a significant seafood business, launching its food products in 1982. Their tartar sauce, with its bold taste and fresh lemon flavor, has garnered a 4.3-star rating on Amazon with over 1,477 reviews. It is praised for its cost-effectiveness, available for $2.68 for a 10.5-ounce bottle, making it a budget-friendly option. The company's revenue ranges between $100 to $500 million annually, reflecting its strong market presence. Explore more about their tartar sauce.

Stonewall Kitchen

Stonewall Kitchen is renowned for its high-quality condiments, particularly its tartar sauces, which are crafted with meticulous attention to detail and premium ingredients. The House Tartar Sauce, a collaboration with Legal Sea Foods, stands out with its unique blend of canola oil, sweet pickle relish, and caramelized onions, making it a favorite among seafood enthusiasts. This 7.75 oz sauce is made in the USA and is free from gluten, though it does contain eggs and soy. With its rich flavor profile and non-GMO alternatives available, Stonewall Kitchen's tartar sauces have garnered a loyal customer base since the brand's inception in 1991. The brand's commitment to quality and taste has earned it a stellar reputation in the specialty food market.

Beaver Brand

Beaver Brand is highly regarded as one of the best producers of tartar sauce, with its Gourmet Seafood Tartar Sauce being an Amazon's Choice product and consistently highly rated by customers. Established in 1929, Beaver Brand has maintained its reputation for quality, with its tartar sauce made and bottled in Oregon, USA. The sauce is praised for its fresh dill flavor, layered with pickles, citrus, capers, and savory spices, making it a beautifully balanced and intensely delicious option. It has been ranked among the top store-bought tartar sauces, with its flavor holding up well in various culinary situations.

Bookbinders Food Products

Bookbinder's Foods is renowned for its high-quality tartar sauce, standing out with its unique blend of fresh ground horseradish and carefully balanced seasonings. This sauce offers a thick, flavorful condiment that sets it apart, although it may not be ideal for those who are not fans of horseradish. Despite some criticisms about the sweetness level, Bookbinder's maintains a decent balance between richness and acidity. Ranked sixth in a comprehensive review of store-bought tartar sauces, it is a notable choice for those seeking a distinctive flavor profile. However, it falls short in terms of pickle texture and sweetness balance.

Frisch's Big Boy

Frisch's Big Boy is renowned for its iconic tartar sauce, a staple in Cincinnati for over 75 years. The sauce, introduced by David Frisch in 1946, is produced by a small family-owned company, Food Specialties, which has been making it for over five decades. Despite Frisch's Big Boy restaurant closures, the tartar sauce production continues, with 1,000 jars produced daily to meet growing demand from retailers like Kroger, Meijer, Sam's, and Walmart. The secret recipe remains unchanged, and the sauce is sold in grocery stores and online, with over 120,000 gallons sold annually. This beloved condiment has become a cultural icon in the region. Discover more about Frisch's Big Boy's market presence.

Stokes Sauces

Stokes Sauces is renowned for its high-quality tartar sauce, offering a traditional favourite that is both vegetarian, dairy-free, and gluten-free. Their tartare sauce is made with coarsely-chopped gherkins and capers, and it contains 10% free-range pasteurised whole egg, 8% capers, and 8% gherkins. This balanced and creamy sauce is ideal for fish and grilled chicken, with nutritional values including 619 kcal of energy per 100g. The ingredients are carefully selected to ensure a tangy and creamy flavor profile. Stokes Sauces ensures that their products are stored properly to maintain freshness, recommending refrigeration after opening and consumption within 6 weeks.