Top Paint Brands for Rental Properties: Maximizing Style and Durability

Choosing the perfect paint for rental properties can significantly enhance the appeal and value, attracting potential tenants with ease. A durable, versatile, and easy-to-maintain paint not only provides a fresh look but also ensures longevity amidst the hustle and bustle of tenant turnovers. In this article, we explore the top paint brands that have consistently impressed landlords and property managers, offering a balance of quality, cost-efficiency, and aesthetic versatility. Get ready to revamp your rental space by discovering the leading paint brands for rentals below.

Illustration of paint for rentals

Best brands of paint for rentals in 2025

Sherwin-Williams

Sherwin-Williams stands out as a leading paint brand, particularly for rentals, with a significant market share and high customer satisfaction. As of 2024, Sherwin-Williams holds 13% of the paint market by unit share and 25% by dollar share, showcasing its upward trend over the past three years. The brand excels in customer service, with paint experts providing recommendations that lead to purchases 88.9% of the time. Sherwin-Williams also ranks high in brand consideration, with 24% of consumers considering the brand during their shopping process. Its commitment to innovation and product excellence has solidified its position as the world's most valuable paints brand for the third consecutive year, with a brand value of USD7.6 billion. For more details about their financial performance, visit their press release.

Behr

Behr is a leading paint brand, particularly suitable for rental properties, with a 30% unit share in the paint market as of March 2024. It is renowned for its durability, wide range of colors, and one-coat coverage, making it a favorite among DIY enthusiasts and professionals. Behr paint is exclusively sold at Home Depot, which holds a 36% unit share in the paint retail market. The brand has seen a 0.8 point increase in its unit share from the previous year, indicating its growing popularity. Its affordability and quality make it an excellent choice for landlords looking to maintain their properties efficiently.

Benjamin Moore

Benjamin Moore is a leading brand in the paint industry, particularly suitable for rental properties due to its high-quality and durable coatings. As of March 2024, Benjamin Moore holds a 5% unit share in the paint market, with a strong presence in both unit and dollar shares. The brand offers a wide range of colors, with over 3,400 shades available, and its products are known for their stain and scuff resistance, making them ideal for high-traffic areas. Benjamin Moore's Aura and Regal Select lines are popular choices, with built-in primers and excellent coverage, ensuring a beautiful and long-lasting finish. The company celebrated its 140th anniversary in 2023, highlighting its long-standing commitment to product innovation and customer satisfaction. For more information, check out the Benjamin Moore website.

Valspar

Valspar is a notable brand in the paint market, particularly for rental properties, given its wide range of architectural paints and coatings. Although it has seen a decline in market share, with a 1.3 point loss in unit share and an 11% brand consideration rate as of March 2024, Valspar remains a significant player. It was acquired by Sherwin-Williams in 2017, which boosted Sherwin-Williams' sales by 27.9% in the second quarter of that year. Valspar's products, including Valspar Paint and Cabot stains, are part of Sherwin-Williams' Consumer Brands Group. Despite the decline, Valspar's average price per ticket is $68, making it a competitive option for rental property owners.

Glidden

Glidden, though not the leading brand, is a significant player in the paint market, particularly for rental properties due to its affordability and quality. As of March 2024, Glidden holds a 6% unit share in the paint market, although it has experienced a significant decline of 1.3 percentage points year-over-year. Despite this, Glidden remains a popular choice for those seeking reliable and cost-effective painting solutions. It is often considered alongside other major brands like Behr and Sherwin Williams, which dominate the market with 30% and 19% unit shares, respectively. Glidden's presence is notable, especially in retail stores where most paint purchases are made. For more details on their paint offerings, visit the Glidden website.

PPG

PPG Industries is a leading producer of high-quality paints and coatings, particularly renowned for its architectural coatings segment, which accounted for 57.2% of its sales in 2015. The company holds approximately 20.8% of the total market share in the paint manufacturing industry, making it a dominant player. PPG's products are widely used in the rental market due to their durability and aesthetic appeal, supported by strong demand from the housing market which has been steadily recovering since 2008. The company's global presence, including operations in Europe, the Americas, Asia Pacific, and other regions, ensures a broad reach and consistent supply. PPG's commitment to innovation and sustainability is further highlighted by its recent $300 million investment in advanced manufacturing to meet growing demand in the automotive sector. For more insights, you can read their financial results for the first quarter of 2024.

Dunn-Edwards

Dunn-Edwards is a leading paint supplier in the Southwestern U.S., particularly renowned for its high-quality products and exceptional customer service, making it a top choice for professionals in the paint and coatings industry. With a market share of 12% in California and 10-20% in neighboring areas, Dunn-Edwards has established a strong presence since its inception in 1925. The company is favored by 72% of licensed painting contractors in Los Angeles, San Diego, and Phoenix, according to an independent survey by Options Marketing Research. Dunn-Edwards' commitment to painting contractors is evident, with over 90% of its paint sold to this segment. The company's Perfect Palette Color System, introduced in 2004, is highly rated by designers and architects for its comprehensive color program. For more information, visit their official website.

Dutch Boy

Dutch Boy Paints is a trusted and innovative brand, particularly beneficial for rental properties due to its durable and easy-to-use products. The brand's new line of Barn & Fence paint, introduced in 2024, offers latex, water-based alkyd, and aluminum formulas, ensuring longevity and aesthetic appeal with features like self-priming, fade-resistance, and mold- and mildew-resistant finishes. Their paints are designed to enhance curb appeal and are available exclusively at Menards, making them a convenient choice for both DIYers and professional contractors. Dutch Boy Paints also emphasizes mindful living with its 2025 One-Coat Color of the Year, Mapped Blue, which is part of a trend forecast focusing on thoughtful and enduring design choices. This commitment to quality and innovation makes Dutch Boy Paints an excellent option for maintaining and improving rental properties. For more information, read about their exclusive line of Barn & Fence and aluminum paints.

Kelly-Moore

Kelly-Moore Paints, founded in 1946 in San Carlos, California, was a renowned producer of premium paints and coatings, particularly favored by professional paint contractors and trade professionals, with 90% of its products sold to this sector. The company operated 157 company-owned retail stores and a network of authorized retailers across North America, generating over $400 million in annual revenues. Kelly-Moore Paints was known for its technologically advanced products manufactured in Hurst, Texas. However, despite its strong legacy, the brand faced significant financial challenges, including legal liabilities and unpaid taxes, leading to its closure in 2024. This closure resulted in the shuttering of over 150 stores and the loss of more than 1,000 jobs. For more details about the closure, visit the acquisition news.

Ace Royal

Ace Hardware's Royal paint brand, now manufactured by Benjamin Moore, is a top choice for rental properties due to its high-quality and durable finishes. With Ace Hardware operating over 4,600 stores in all 50 states and more than 60 countries, the brand's reach is extensive. Benjamin Moore's takeover of manufacturing for Ace's private label paints, including Royal, ensures premium interior and exterior paint options. This partnership enhances the brand's reputation for reliability and performance, making it a preferred choice for landlords and property managers. The brand's inclusion in Ace Hardware's $9.1 billion in full-year revenues for 2023 underscores its significance in the market.