Top Eggnog Brands to Elevate Your Holiday Cheer

Eggnog, a cherished holiday staple, has been delighting taste buds with its creamy and spicy flavors for generations. With a variety of brands on the market, finding the best options can enhance your festive experience. From classic recipes to unique twists, these brands pledge to deliver exceptional taste and quality in every sip. For those looking to savor the best, explore our curated list of top eggnog brands below.

Illustration of eggnog

Best brands of eggnog in 2025

Southern Comfort

Southern Comfort, a renowned American whiskey liqueur brand, has also made a name for itself as a premium producer of eggnog, particularly with its spiked eggnog recipes. Introduced in 1874 by Martin Wilkes Heron, the brand has a rich history and has undergone several formulations, including a return to its original whiskey-based recipe in 2017. Southern Comfort eggnog, available in various flavors, is a holiday favorite, combining the brand's 100 proof whiskey with traditional eggnog ingredients for a decadent and creamy drink. The recipe typically includes ingredients like egg yolks, sugar, heavy whipping cream, and spices, with the addition of 1/4 cup of Southern Comfort for a 21% ABV kick. This festive cocktail is perfect for the winter season and can be stored in the fridge for up to two weeks. For more details on how to create this delightful treat, visit the Southern Comfort eggnog recipe page.

Evan Williams

Evan Williams, a renowned brand from Heaven Hill Distilleries, is a leading producer of eggnog, particularly with its Evan Williams Original Southern Egg Nog, which has become a holiday tradition since its introduction. This eggnog is made with extra-aged Evan Williams Bourbon, real dairy cream, and other fine spirits, offering a rich and creamy holiday cocktail. Bottled at 30 proof or 15% alcohol by volume, it is available in 750ml and 1.75 liter sizes from October through New Year's Day. The brand also offers a Peppermint Chocolate flavor extension, launched in 2012, which adds a contemporary twist to the traditional recipe. Evan Williams Egg Nog is highly regarded, with the original version being one of the nation's top-selling seasonal spirits.

Hood

Hood is New England's #1 eggnog brand, based on gallon volume sales data, and has been a holiday staple for generations. Their eggnog products, such as Vanilla Eggnog and Golden Eggnog, are made with premium milk, cream, and special spices, offering 180 calories per 1/2 cup serving with 9g of total fat and 21g of total sugars. Hood's commitment to quality and innovation has ensured their products remain a favorite, with sales growth even in a flat to declining market category. The company celebrates 175 years of operation and manufactures over 4,000 SKUs across various dairy products. Hood's products are widely available in supermarkets, club stores, and other channels.

Organic Valley

Organic Valley, America's largest organic farmer-owned dairy cooperative, has been recognized for its exceptional Organic Reduced Fat Eggnog, which won the 2024 Product of the Year USA Award in the Specialty Dairy Beverage category. This award was determined by a national study of 40,000 American shoppers, highlighting the product's made-from-scratch recipe using organic milk and eggs from cows and chickens raised without antibiotics, synthetic hormones, toxic pesticides, or GMOs. The eggnog is available from September through December and is crafted with organic ingredients such as milk, sugar, cream, egg yolks, and natural flavor. Consumers preferred this new reduced fat recipe over the prior full fat version, as evidenced by internal and third-party testing. Organic Valley's commitment to ethical sourcing and sustainable farming practices makes their eggnog a standout in the market.

Trader Joe’s

Trader Joe's is renowned for its rich and creamy eggnog, a seasonal favorite that returns to store shelves every November. The brand's Regular and Light Egg Nog varieties are particularly popular, although the Regular Egg Nog is generally preferred by nog aficionados. In 2023, these products began appearing in stores on November 1, marking the official start of the holiday season. Trader Joe's eggnog is highly regarded for its taste and quality, with many customers loyal to the brand's traditional and authentic flavors. Despite the lack of a non-dairy nog option in 2023, Trader Joe's remains a top choice for eggnog enthusiasts. You can read more about their festive eggnog in this article.

Pennsylvania Dutch

Pennsylvania Dutch Eggnog is a renowned holiday beverage, produced by Dairyland Distillers Co., part of Jacquin's, based in Philadelphia. This pre-mixed cocktail boasts a 14.75% ABV, blending rum, brandy, and blended whiskey, and is released only during the holidays with a seven-month shelf life. It combines real dairy cream with warming spices like nutmeg and cinnamon, offering a rich and velvety texture. With a century of experience, Pennsylvania Dutch ensures artisanal taste and authentic flavor in small batches. This eggnog is a classic representation of Pennsylvania's dairy traditions and the heritage of its Dutch community. Find more about this traditional holiday beverage.

Ronnybrook

Ronnybrook Farm Dairy is renowned for its high-quality eggnog, often described as the "Dom Perignon" of dairy products by The New York Times. Their eggnog, available from November to January, has been rated highly in New York by the Huffington Post and featured on the Food Network. In 2017, Ronnybrook's eggnog received a 4.5 overall rating for its delicious and creamy texture, although it was noted for its higher carrageenan and guar gum levels. The farm's commitment to humane treatment of animals and minimal processing of dairy products adds to the appeal of their eggnog. Ronnybrook's traditional farming practices and use of grass-fed cows further enhance the quality of their dairy products.

Lucerne

Lucerne is renowned as one of the best producers of eggnog, offering a rich, velvety, and flavorful dairy-based product. Their eggnog contains key ingredients like milk, sugars, cream, and frozen yolk, with a nutritional profile of 160 calories, 8g of fat, and 18g of sugars per 1/2 cup serving. It is pasteurized and homogenized, ensuring a consistent quality. Lucerne's eggnog is also notable for its absence of antibiotic residues and artificial growth hormones, aligning with Canadian dairy regulations. This product is a popular choice for both its taste and versatility in recipes.

Darigold

Darigold is renowned as one of the best producers of eggnog, offering a rich custard flavor with hints of nutmeg and a smooth, creamy consistency that is a family favorite during the holiday season. Their eggnog is locally sourced from Northwest farmers who do not use the artificial growth hormone rbST, ensuring high quality and safety. With ultra-pasteurization for a long shelf life and an easy-pour cap, Darigold's eggnog is convenient and delicious. Each serving contains 190 calories, 9g of total fat, and 18g of total sugars, making it an indulgent yet satisfying treat. Darigold handles approximately 10 billion pounds of milk annually, highlighting their significant presence in the dairy industry.

Silk

Silk, owned by Danone, is a leading brand in the non-dairy market, recognized by over 85% of milk substitutes consumers in the U.S. as of 2023. While Silk is primarily known for its plant-based milk alternatives, its brand strength and consumer loyalty, particularly among Baby Boomers and Generation X, position it as a potential contender for non-dairy eggnog options. Silk consumers value safety and security, which aligns with the trust and reliability needed for a successful non-dairy eggnog product. However, specific data on Silk's non-dairy eggnog is not available, but its strong brand presence suggests it could be a viable option. With half of all milk alternatives consumers in the U.S. liking the Silk brand, it has a significant consumer base to leverage for new product lines. For more detailed insights, you can visit the Silk brand profile on Statista.