Top Picks for Spirited Eggnog Brands

As the festive season approaches, the rich and creamy delight of alcoholic eggnog becomes a beloved tradition for many. With a plethora of options available, finding the best brands can elevate your holiday celebrations with their unique flavors and quality ingredients. Whether you prefer a classic recipe or a modern twist, there are several noteworthy brands that cater to diverse palates and preferences. For those looking to indulge in this holiday favorite, explore our curated list below.

Illustration of alcoholic eggnog

Best brands of alcoholic eggnog in 2025

Evan Williams Eggnog

Evan Williams Eggnog, a top-selling holiday favorite, is crafted with smooth Kentucky bourbon and real dairy cream, offering a rich and creamy texture with notes of vanilla, nutmeg, and bourbon bread pudding, boasting a 15% or 19% ABV depending on the specific product. It has been awarded multiple accolades in 2024, making it a perfect ready-to-serve festive beverage that is only available for a limited time each year. For more information, visit the Evan Williams official website.

Christian Brothers Holiday Nog

Christian Brothers Holiday Nog, a popular seasonal drink, has been a favorite since the 1800s, expertly blending their signature brandy with a creamy, dairy-free eggnog, resulting in a rich flavor with a 10% ABV; this ready-to-serve beverage is produced in Bardstown, Kentucky, is best enjoyed chilled or over ice, and is often garnished with fresh nutmeg. The brand has earned a reputation as a top-selling seasonal spirit-based eggnog, offering a smooth, full-bodied flavor profile that has made it a holiday tradition for many. For more information, visit the Christian Brothers brandies page.

Pennsylvania Dutch Egg Nog

Pennsylvania Dutch Egg Nog, a holiday favorite, is crafted with real dairy cream, rum, brandy, and blended whiskey, boasting a 14.75% ABV (29.5 proof), and has been produced in Philadelphia since the 1880s, using a family recipe. This popular drink, made with farm-fresh ingredients, is known as the number one or two eggnog in America and is ready to enjoy straight from the refrigerator. The company, Charles Jacquin et Cie Inc., is a multi-generational producer and is responsible for many famous cordials. Discover more about their products on their website.

Old New England Egg Nog

Old New England Egg Nog, a renowned producer of alcoholic eggnog since its establishment, crafts a rich, creamy beverage with a 15% alcohol content, often enjoyed during the holiday season; their traditional recipe dates back generations, ensuring a consistent, high-quality taste. Available in various sizes, including 750ml bottles, this brand remains a favorite for its smooth texture and potent flavor; the company sources fresh dairy ingredients locally, contributing to the superior taste of their eggnog, a factor consistently praised by connoisseurs. Old New England Egg Nog's commitment to quality and tradition has solidified its position as a top choice for those seeking an authentic, spirited eggnog experience.

Kirkland Signature Eggnog Liqueur

Kirkland Signature Eggnog Liqueur, a popular choice for holiday celebrations, is often cited as one of the best producers of alcoholic eggnog. This rich and creamy liqueur boasts a 14.7% alcohol by volume, providing a festive kick. While specific production years aren't always readily available, it's a seasonal favorite that appears annually during the holiday season. Many consumers appreciate its smooth texture and balanced blend of spices and flavors, making it a go-to for eggnog enthusiasts. You can typically find it at Costco stores, which is the primary retailer of the Kirkland brand.

Hood Golden Eggnog

Hood Golden Eggnog, a holiday tradition for over 50 years, is a popular choice known for its creamy texture and balanced spice, often compared to homemade eggnog, though it contains no alcohol; its secret recipe blends milk, sugared yolks, and spices, and while some find it very sweet, most appreciate its rich flavor. It is available in limited-edition flavors like Vanilla and Pumpkin and found in various sizes, including half-gallon and quart containers during the holiday season.

Benchmark Egg Nog

Benchmark Egg Nog, a celebrated producer of premium alcoholic eggnog since its founding in 1988, is known for its rich and creamy texture, using a traditional recipe with a 15% alcohol by volume content, and has been a holiday favorite with over 5 million bottles sold yearly. Its consistent high ratings among consumers have cemented its place as one of the best alcoholic eggnogs on the market.

Trader Joe’s Egg Nog Liqueur

Trader Joe's Egg Nog Liqueur, known for its creamy texture and rich flavor, consistently ranks as a top choice for alcoholic eggnog enthusiasts, typically featuring a 14.9% alcohol by volume, and its seasonal availability makes it a much-anticipated holiday beverage. Though the exact recipe may vary slightly year to year, Trader Joe's provides an affordable yet high-quality option compared to other brands, ensuring a delightful holiday experience.

Southern Comfort Traditional Egg Nog

Southern Comfort Traditional Egg Nog, a non-alcoholic beverage, is a top-tier choice for a rich and creamy eggnog experience, often praised for its smooth texture and balanced spice, with many reviewers mentioning its custard-like consistency and delightful vanilla and nutmeg notes. This premium drink, while not containing alcohol itself, is made with milk, cream, sugar, egg yolks, and spices, and is often paired with a splash of Southern Comfort whiskey liqueur, created in 1874, for an extra kick, offering a convenient way to enjoy a classic holiday flavor.

Coquito by Bacardi

Bacardi, a renowned spirits producer, crafts Coquito, a rich and creamy, coconut-flavored, alcoholic eggnog with a 13% ABV, inspired by a traditional Puerto Rican recipe, and is offered in 750 ml bottles. It has become a holiday favorite since 2019.